How to compare two auto insurance quotes

Put two quotes side by side and see how to spot differences in liability limits, deductibles, vehicle protection, and who is listed to drive.

Two quotes can look alike until you compare the details line by line. Set them next to each other, and keep your current declarations page handy if you have one. Check that the quotes are for the same policy term before comparing the price.

Start with the same drivers and cars

Make sure both quotes list the same vehicles and drivers. Confirm how each vehicle is used and where it is usually kept. If someone delivers goods or drives to job sites for work, ask how that use is handled rather than assuming it is included.

Compare the amounts on each line

Look at the limits listed for injury and property damage liability. Then look for coverage for your own car, such as collision or comprehensive, and note each deductible. Don’t assume a missing line means it’s included somewhere else. Ask what would pay to repair your car after an accident you caused and what might pay after a theft or hail loss.

Check the extras before deciding

If rental reimbursement, towing, or another option matters to you, look for it on both quotes and ask about its limit. Finish by comparing the payment schedules: a monthly payment doesn’t tell you what the whole policy term costs, especially if there’s a down payment.

For more background, see the Texas Department of Insurance auto insurance guide. Actual coverage depends on the policy.